Archive for the ‘Google’ Category

Is Facebook really a strong ad platform?

This week I was interviewed by Martin Giles of the Economist for his excellent article about the Facebook IPO.

This subject is by no means small beans for online marketers because the reality is that Facebook is indeed one of the most powerful platforms for consumer marketing that exists today. Why do I think this?

Well, firstly a Facebook page is uniquely an environment where the content has been written specifically by, or for, the individual user who owns that page. It’s highly personal and therefore some of the most powerfully engaging content a user will experience on the web. Placing an advertising message in such highly prized content almost guarantees it gets noticed (provided it’s made relevant, which is sadly still a problem advertisers have not solved in most cases on Facebook)

Secondly, the home page, unlike many web pages, has relatively little ad clutter. Facebook needs to watch this because I see a worrying trend of more and more ads on my page, but generally speaking only a very small percentage of ad page real estate is dedicated to ad messages.

Thirdly, the user profiling for advertisers will only get better. Already users voluntarily give up a ton of personal data to Facebook that can be used to target ads. The audience segmentation is vast and so it’s really quite easy to develop ad messages that are relevant to the consumer… it’s just that most advertisers are too lazy to do it.

With all this said there are still issues. Firstly, the Facebook model is having trouble scaling. Minimum serviced media buys start at $50K. If you have less than that you must buy through a self service online model. There are lots of potential advertisers who will not want to spend that amount.

Performance data is harder to come by with Facebook campaigns and that will undoubtedly slow growth with agencies and clients that use data for modelling.

As per Martins article the mobile platform is also a challenge since growth in traffic there if not monetized will leave big dollars on the table.

Facebook really needs more advertiser tools, so it’s future may depend upon companies like Wildfire Interactive who have the ability to help craft and build Facebook campaigns and pages that ultimately grow user engagement.  Many brands are adopting such tools and as they see campaign work the growth in commitment to this Facebook audience will grow, as will revenues.

Finally the biggest question of all… will Facebook still be huge in 5 years time? Valid question if you recall MySpace and it’s fall from grace. I know a lot of Facebookers and the ones who were most active several years ago hardly post at all now. However, new users and the younger generation are still really quite active and it’s still a massive global audience on offer. Personally, I don’t see it going anywhere for a while. Even with new social competitors the reality is Facebook has captured a large slice of pie and users will need something compelling to just up and leave. I don’t see any clamor for example from my network to move wholesale to Google+.

So yes Facebook is a powerful ad platform but it will only grow with better servicing of the advertising community and a continuation of it’s ability to micro target users. Sadly this may take more time than the street now gives it time for and I expect dissapointing results to hurt Facebook before they get the ad model right.

Dick Reed, CEO. Just Media, Inc.

 

 

 

Media Agency CEO slams Google metrics announcement

Google has announced its vision for a suite of new Internet measurement tools that it hopes will bring more brand advertisers to the web and increase the online share of media budget. The details of the announcement of Active GRP’s and Active Views are available at this Google Doubleclick blog.

I have serious issues with this announcement for a number of reasons.

Firstly, Google has, in many ways, been the creator of many of today’s online metrics problems. It was the first major online media vendor to focus entirely on the “click”; introducing the search and display cost per click and performance buying model. In doing so it sold the marketing community on the concept that the only intrinsic value of online was users actually clicking on an ad, since this is all they asked you to pay for.  By default, it eliminated any value associated with having a marketing message seen by millions of users who did not decide to react to it instantly. That put us back 10 years as an industry.

Secondly since the purchasing of the DoubleClick tools like Dart for Advertisers (DFA) & Dart for Publishers (DFP) and  in 2008, the pace of development of that tool has been staggeringly slow. Key industry metrics like ‘path to conversion’ (mostly promoted by rival Microsoft, who interestingly enough failed to compete in search with CPC, but operated a much more significant display network and had alternative motivations for seeing display value developed through metrics), promotion of the use of view-through-data and developing meaningful dashboards were so stifled that in 2010, after more than ten years as a DFA house, Just Media, Inc., switched adserver platforms. Integration with Google Analytics was noticeable by its absence too.

OK, so let’s look at the news.

Active View: Good. It’s nice to think the industry might be finally asking whether an ad is actually seen by a user. It’s a metric the online industry should leverage because no other media channel can give that. However, if Google expects publishers to only get paid for ads they actually deliver, they might want to start getting ready for some interesting conversations. In a recent test with our trading desk, the tool reported 70% of the ads appeared “above the fold”. Let’s, for the sake of argument, assume the 30% of ads below the fold were not seen, publishers are going to be mighty resistant to eliminating a possible 30% of revenue without raising the price for viewed impressions. Of course networks that sell remnant inventory might be even more challenged as the low value impressions buried in sites may have even more to lose in visibility and hence value. But overall a metric we should develop further.

Active GRP:  Really? Is using a panel based audience tool the best the online industry can come up with? Or are we finally admitting that we have to dumb down our metrics to those used by an industry that was established in the 1950’s? Shouldn’t the reality be that the TV industry should be dragged kicking and screaming into the 2010’s and held to a higher level of accountability? Isn’t this just a reaction in order to pander to agency and client executives who have failed to embrace developing consumer metrics and try and apply them to other media channels? I’m sorry, but I cannot give a free pass to using metrics that take us back in time simply to try and grab a bigger slice of the media pie. If we do, can we also re-introduce smoking and drinking in the office while we are at it.

Finally, as with many things Google, there appears to be no attempt made to bring in these metrics industry wide. I’d have been more impressed had Google announced an open metric platform; open to the whole industry rather than some new “product features” for DoubleClick. It’s simply unreasonable for Google to think they can introduce new standards if they are only available to a few customers.

Come on Google is this the best you have for us? I’m underwhelmed.

DICK REED, CEO
Just Media, Inc.

Email: dick@justmedia.com
Follow: @JustMediaUS
www.justmedia.com

Every Impression Counts: Part One

CEO, Dick Reed, explores the advantages of Just Media, Inc’s ”Every Impression Counts” philosophy and some of the key ramifications on planning and measurement when this approach is applied to advertising campaigns.

The first part of this two part white paper is available now on Just Media, Inc’s website by following this link: http://justmedia.com/blog/signup/ or by sending an email directly to CEO@justmedia.com.

As always, any feedback and thoughts on the paper and it’s topic are very much appreciated and welcomed.

The next player in B2B social media?

Just Media, Inc’s Media Planner, Cristina Lehman, recently joined the Pinterest social networking site and offers her thoughts on this new and exclusive player in the online social world.

“I just recently discovered Pinterest and a couple weeks ago, I finally got my invite to join (yes, it’s invite only!).  If you haven’t used or heard of Pinterest, it’s a really cool social networking site where users create boards and “pin” or post interesting photos from different websites or by uploading their own photos.  The boards can be categorized by topic and then other people can comment on each photo.  It was one of the top ten most visited social sites in 2011!  Right now I see it as more of a B2C social site, but eventually, I can see it moving towards B2B as it gains in popularity.”

“Per this article on mashable.com (http://mashable.com/2012/01/10/pinterest-business-consumer-engagement/), there are a couple of ways that brands can utilize Pinterest to their advantage.  I thought two of these would be a great way to interact with customers: “New product approval” and “display various sectors of a company”. 

The first, new product approval, can be used as a pseudo-focus group.  I think this is a great way for companies to introduce a product in the early stages and see how consumers react to it by how many “pins” and “repins” they get.  They can also monitor comments on what they post. 

The second, displaying various sectors of a company, would be a great way to showcase a company – its products, people and company culture - and that would help build awareness and further interest in a company.  The article goes into further detail about these two and other ways to utilize Pinterest.  I personally love this site and have never really been this into other social sites.  It’s a great way to categorize things that you like and find new things you never would have known about.”

On the hunt for a DSP

Last year Just Media, Inc., decided to bring a DSP in house. Easier said than done! Weeks and weeks of research and presentations followed. Interestingly enough, it was hard to get a sales person to come to the office or even just reach one on the phone. In one instance I tried several times to set up an appointment and the sales person either cancelled, didn’t show or simply didn’t respond in a timely fashion so we had to pick yet another date only to start all over (cancelling, no-show …)

Most platforms we looked at offered the same capabilities, with sometimes the only difference being how much client service they promised. Besides guaranteed brand safety and the quality of inventory, sophisticated audience targeting options and easy reporting/data visualization; we had a self-serve platform in mind. MediaMath made the cut in the end and we’ve been very happy with this decision ever since. It comes as no surprise that they got very high scores in “The Forrester Wave TM: Demand-Side Platforms, Q4 2011”.

Check out the study here on MediaMath’s homepage: “http://www.mediamath.com/solutions/forresterwave.”

I’d love to find out why Google didn’t want to participate in the study!

Happy analyzing!

Frauke Cast, Trafficking & Analytics Manager

Cyber Monday & Mobile Ads

On Cyber Monday, Susan Redgrave, Just Media’s Trafficking & Analytics Specialist, shares her timely thoughts on the use of mobile ads:

“I recently broke down and traded my old school Blackberry in for the ‘new and improved’ iPhone 4s. What I didn’t entirely realize was that this would then open me up to the world of mobile advertising, which I have to say, did not make me the happiest consumer on the market. This I’m sure will strike at least some of you as surprising as I dearly love my work in the online marketing and advertising industry; and to be fair, in general I DO love advertising. I am one of “those” people who dig when a company can target a banner or textlink or even a whitepaper to me based solely on my previous searching or clicking. However, with mobile advertising, I dislike when ads pop up during my very important Angry Birds game. Although, I have been told that if I break down and pay for the game those ads will cease. All of that being said and to try to give you a little background on my feelings on the subject, I am writing this because after attending this awesome webinar the other day, I actually can see the value and promise in mobile ads. The webinar was called, “Mobile Advertising: Right Person, Right Time, Right Message” and was presented by Avinash Kaushik. I would say that for most people out there (including skeptics like me) it is virtually impossible to listen to this gentleman speak on mobile advertising and analytics and NOT get excited. He is extremely passionate about these two subjects and presented us with many examples of how and why mobile advertising is important to our ever changing technology driven lives.”

“One of the many ways to use mobile advertising involves when our shopping goes offline; which may appear to be counter intuitive at first, but hear me out. Now-a-days many of the products that we use everyday have the QR code on them. We can use our mobile devices to scan those bar codes which will usually bring us to different pages and examples about products that we are considering purchasing. Avinash mentioned that he was recently at Costco and bought a box of strawberries that had one of these QR codes on them. Now, personally I wouldn’t think of trying to scan a box of strawberries and have it show me anything of interest, but in his case, it did. The code brought him to a page that told him more about the company, but more importantly for me; it gave him recipes for him to try. As a mom of an 8 month old and who also happens to work full time, I am always on the lookout for new recipes to try. I immediately thought that whoever is running the marketing at the strawberry company needs a raise as I would never have thought about doing this before. At the very least this has made me remember the brand and because I had a good experience, I will most likely choose this brand over another one that is in the store.”

“He also mentioned that he recently was in the market to buy a new TV set and went to a local store to check them out and to do some research. To him they all looked the same. But one of them had a QR code on it so he scanned it; leading him to the amazing site that told him everything he wanted and needed to know about the TV. I know that anytime I am out shopping I almost always pull out my iPhone and try to search on Google or Amazon for whatever it is that I am thinking about buying. I rely more and more on other consumer’s reviews and honestly I reject a lot of products based simply on the score I see the minute that I search for a product.”

“As our society goes more and more mobile, this is going to be that much more important. I think that even the skeptics among us need to embrace and understand that this world of mobile advertising is only going to get bigger and so much more important. We are using our mobile devices in almost every aspect of our lives and I think this is an area of advertising that could potentially become bigger than ‘traditional’ online advertising. I can’t speak for anyone but myself, but I am hardly ever without my phone and this gives the advertisers an opportunity to turn me on to their products almost 24 hours a day and not just the hour or two that I spend online on my laptop.”

For more information about Just Media, Inc., and how a mobile campaign could work for your business, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us. Contact: John O’Connor, Director of Partnership Development. johnoconnor@justmedia.com.

Fun (Google) Insight

Just Media’s Junior Online Media Trafficker, Ieva ‘Eve’ Rukuizaite‘s day was brightened by a Google alert:

“I like how Google is always there for you: It tells you the closest places for great food; provides product reviews; gives you directions to places; has a database of zillions of pictures; and it takes care of most of your Search needs. It is there when you need it and it knows (OK, kind of knows) what you need.

I wanted to share my little interaction with Google today. In one of the Google email blasts that I get on a daily basis, I found one piece of information that totally made my day. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. Who would have thought that NY is more interested in flip-flops than people in the Golden State?”

Find out the answer by clicking here:

A View from The Top: Past, Present, Future. ‘Live!’

To celebrate Just Media’s 15 years of successful business in California, we recently hosted a day of thought leadership and discussion: A View From The Top – Past, Present, Future; featuring key CEO’s, decision makers and industry leaders, who discussed their thoughts on the evolution of media and the ever changing and challenging world of IT marketing.

Video of the four sessions is now available through our technology partner BrightTALK™ and by clicking the following links you will be able to access the full sessions from the live event.

A VIEW FROM THE TOP – PAST, PRESENT, FUTURE
Senior executives from agencies, media organizations and clients came together for a stimulating morning of discussion focusing on the ever changing and challenging world of IT marketing.

Session 1: Looking Back And Looking Forward
Steve Weitzner, CEO, Ziff Davis Enterprise
Dick Reed, CEO, Just Media, Inc.

Dick and Steve discuss how the IT media publisher and agency have had to adapt and evolve over the years to address the changes in the media landscape and continue to best service both the IT audience and tech marketing client.

Session 2: Leveraging Brand Value
Josh Kahn, VP, Private Cloud Marketing, EMC
Marlene Williamson, VP, Global Marketing, Hitachi Global Storage Technologies
David Appelbaum, CMO, Act-On Software

Josh, Marlene and David discuss the challenges and opportunities that exist for tech companies to really leverage maximum value from their brand.

Session 3: Content Is King, But Distribution Is Key
Tony Uphoff, CEO, UBM TechWeb
Val-Pierre Genton, VP, Business Development, BrightTALK™

Tony and Val discuss the importance of generating great content and the issues and challenges with getting that content to the audience, given the ever more distributed communications channels.

Session 4: Social Media And The IT Professional
Matt Sweeney, CRO, Geeknet
Roger Warner, MD, Content & Motion
Sarah du Heaume, Founder, Just Media, Inc.

Sarah, Matt and Roger explore what it takes to build and manage successful social media environments specifically created for IT professionals.

You will need to register with BrightTALK™ in order to view the content.

We hope you enjoy the video discussion and find it stimulating and relevant. Please don’t hesitate to contact Just Media with any comments or questions or if you would like to learn more about Just Media and our services. As always, we welcome your feedback.

Is it Really Possible to Improve Your AdWords Quality Score with Google +1?

Just Media’s online trafficker Ieva ‘Eve’ Ruzuikaite offers some thought and insight in response to the following article:

Is it Really Possible to Improve Your AdWords Quality Score with Google +1?

http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2109663/Is-it-Really-Possible-to-Improve-Your-AdWords-Quality-Score-with-Google-1

Eve says: “There has been a lot of buzz about Google +1 lately. I will be honest, it is not that I don’t care about Google +1 or that I don’t see its possible potential, but I really think that while some new things are worth attention right away, some, like fruits, need more time to ripen. That is my take on Google +1.”

“That said, I don’t think you should concentrate on putting a lot of effort collecting Google +1s when it comes to AdWords Quality Score. You will have better use of your time if you revise your negative keyword list, add more relevant keywords, test more ads, make your ads more relevant to your product and your landing pages and test different offers and calls to action. At the end of the day it won’t matter how many Google +1s you have, but how well you manage your time doing things that are proven to work. That’s my take on Google +1. Manage your time wisely and try new things in small batches.”

Happy AdWord-ing!

Germany issues new guidelines for data protection

Being German myself, I am always interested in what’s going on in my home country. Especially when it comes to cookies (and I’m not talking about the delicious Holiday cookies I had when I visited in November last year) and online metrics. I found this article last week that talks about the issues Google Analytics is running into in the German market. Looks like the end user might get in trouble when using it…

Germans have very high standards when it comes to privacy and they have a healthy suspicion about giving away information about themselves. But that’s not enough. Apparently data protection companies are helping with securing privacy in their own way. Under the new guidelines, not only will Google get in trouble, but the company who uses it might be in difficulty too. Click here for the article

I could imagine that a lot of companies were actually excited about using Google Analytics as it gives smaller companies the ability to quickly analyze what’s going on with their web site. I happen to love the tool. It’s not rocket science, it tells you what you are looking for fairly quickly and if set up correctly it is able to give you amazing insight about how the visitor behaves on your site. But looking at campaign data from BOTH ends – our ad serving reporting and the web analytics tool on the site that hosts the landing page – shows us the full picture. It’s a common mistake that clients believe they can see everything about a campaign through their web analytics tool only. This is only half the picture. We optimize campaigns based on several metrics, including Cost per Click, Cost per Landing, Click to Landing Ratio and view-through data. We still glance at the Click-through-rate but that’s just the first check point. From this set of metrics, only one can be compared to a number of the web analytics program: the landings should be close to the number of visitors to that page through the campaign. Everything else, especially the view-through data, can only be captured through our ad serving program. Here often lies the true success of a campaign. How often do we really click on a banner? I find myself searching for the banner content more often than clicking and that’s exactly what will be captured: users that were exposed to the banner, didn’t click, but came to the page later on. Most likely through a Search.

Dick Reed actually wrote an interesting and detailed whitepaper about tech metrics a while ago (Tech Marketing Analytics 101 Part 1- ROI). Check it out here:

Happy trafficking!
Frauke Cast